In this episode of the CFO project podcast, we answer your questions around value pricing. And.
Welcome to the CFO project podcast. Today we're talking all about value pricing. To help me with the discussion, I've invited the master himself to mark Wickersham from Value Pricing Academy. Mark, welcome to the show. Well, thank you for inviting me. Adam. This is awesome. I'm really looking forward to this. Yeah. So we have some good questions around value pricing, but I guarantee you there's probably somebody thinking what is value pricing exactly.
So what is value pricing. Yeah that's a great question to start with. And so I first got into value pricing. I came across it way back in 1999 when I was running my accounting firm in the UK as a sole as a sole practitioner. And up until then, I spent the first three years with timesheets, time based billing and I was making a crazy mess of it.
I was way too cheap not making money, struggling until I came across value pricing. And so essentially is this there are only really two ways of pricing and that's it, two ways of pricing. There are lots of different methods of pricing. Things like a time based billing as a method of pricing, as is dynamic pricing, demand based pricing, percentage pricing, contingent pricing.
There are many ways to calculate price, but they all fall into one of two types of pricing. One is cost plus pricing, where we add up the hours, or we add up the cost and add on add on our hoped for profit margin, of which time based billing is a form of cost plus pricing, which is a terrible way to price.
And the other way is value pricing and value pricing is we ignore costs. What we do is we start with a customer. We start with what do they value, what's the value to them. And we price based on that value. So the greater the value we create for our clients, or at least their perception of the value, then the higher the price.
Yeah, I mean, it makes sense on a conceptual level, but I know a lot of accountants aren't doing it, because if you think about like a house whose houses are sold based on value, not based on cost, I mean, if you bought your house in the 70s, the cost today is significantly low. But but the value is going to be probably be significantly higher.
So if we could sell it there value pricing, why can't we sell it? Why do most accountants struggle with selling it with our accounting services? They struggle, I think partly because we have grown up with this idea of keeping timesheets. I was brought up in the profession I entered in 1988. The firm I worked for, you had to keep timesheets.
And so we the time she gives us that kind of mentality of focusing on hours or costs. Also, I think another reason is because one of the, one of the things about accounting professionals of which I am one is we like everything to be accurate. And the thing about timesheets is it feels like we have an accurate, precise calculation of price.
Even though I say even though it's accurately and precisely wrong, it's it fails as accuracy, whereas unfortunately value pricing is is very much judgment based. It's and it's, it's difficult because value itself, as my friend Ron Baker once said, is value is in the hearts and minds of customers. Everybody values things differently. It's also, subjective. You can't touch, feel, measure, value.
It's very much a feeling. It's very much a judgment. That's why I think we struggle in the profession, because we're more comfortable with having something that seems to be accurate, like adding up hours on the timesheet. I love that. I love that response. Yeah. I couldn't agree more. Well, I know we have some good questions for us, Mark.
So what's our first question? Tamara wants to know. I offer both bookkeeping and advisory services. It's easy to explain the value of my advisory services, but I'm finding it difficult to explain the value of my bookkeeping services. What would you advise me? That's a good question. What are your thoughts? But it is a very good question from Tamara.
And it is one of the most common questions I get because of all of the services we offer, with the exception of clean up work. I think bookkeeping is one of the hardest ones that people struggle to value price. And, and, and a lot of the reason for that is because we're so obsessed with scope and how long things will take.
And certainly that is important. And we want to make sure we make a profit on the job. But we should be focusing on the profit. So I also on the value on the value of, of what we do. So some of the things that we should do in and actually just an aside, a lot of people think the value pricing is just about coming up with a price and number.
But actually the more we studied value pricing, we realized that the number one skill that we have to master is communication. How do we communicate the value to the customer? If the customer can't see the value, they'll always say, that's too expensive. So how do we do that with bookkeeping? Well, the first thing, the first point I would make is that we have to address the pain points.
We have to make sure that we build up in their mind the pain, the challenges, the problems. For example, it takes time. It's stressful. It's difficult. We should also talk about the strategic value. What is the value of bookkeeping? What is the what is the end result? What would their life be like? What will it feel like when they've got a great set of books?
That's an accurate information. And then we can also build up value by using case studies, stories, stories of on on the one hand, businesses that we've come across have had terrible books and records and the problems that's created, like, for example, visits from the IRS because they've not kept proper records and also case studies, stories of business owners who have gone on top of that, that bookkeeping, understand the numbers and are making better decisions, building better, decision making, making better decisions to build better businesses.
So we want to focus on how do we communicate value with looking at the pain, the problems, the challenges, and what would life look like if we had a perfect set of books and records? What sort of business can we build? Yeah, I love that. And I love how you you communicated the fact that it's all about the communication, like it's all about how you present things to the client.
Because we all have to remember that our clients, business owners, they're not accountants, they're not bookkeepers. They don't know the difference between a good bookkeeper and a bad one. So how can they judge? The only thing they can judge on is based on how you make them feel and your communication, and to how you present bookkeeping services.
Absolutely. It is all about communication. It's about the words that we use, how we build that up. And one of the things that I'm a big fan of for pricing is having, pricing brochures that become, if you like, our agenda or script for the meeting, to make sure we say the right things. Yeah. And we have to use lots of techniques, like, for example, turning features into benefits.
We're very good at talking about the features of what we do. We might say to a client, one of the things we do as part of your bookkeeping is we reconcile your bank account, and I can guarantee that you have never, ever, ever, ever heard a business owner then say, oh, wow, that's amazing. You reconcile the bank account.
That's extraordinary. That will be so valuable because they have no idea. They have no idea. So what we do is figure out how do we turn that feature, which is extremely valuable, into a benefit to the customer? Totally. I would argue that most business owners have no clue what doing the books actually even mean. What does that mean?
What are books like that? That's all the computer, right? Absolutely. What does it mean? They don't value? I totally agree. I also think it's interesting that the Tamara is a bookkeeper, an advisor. So I'm wondering if if she could say something to the effect of, look, I'm going to make sure your books are done. I'm going to make sure your, your your numbers are correct and they're timely.
That's a no brainer. I will do that. But I will also make sure you have a better future. So I'm not only going to keep the past and make sure the past is recorded accurately, but I'm going to make sure you have a better future. And that's what I'm really passionate about. And I think that kind of communication will also help the business.
Want to make a decision to hire Tamara? That's brilliant. Adam. Yes, I love that everybody listening. If you haven't already, sign up for a five minute weekly email with practical tips for accountants and bookkeepers to escape the accountants trap, go to the CFO project.com/newsletter. How excellent. All right, so what's our next question? Lisa wants to know how do I know what to charge for my advisory services.
Is it by size of the client by amount of work or something else? Good question. What do you think? And the mark. I value we value price is through as with everything. And it's sort of a softball question I probably. Yeah. So so we price based on value and certainly in the case of advisory absolutely never about how many hours it's going to take us.
Because the great thing about advisory as opposed to compliance work with advisory, we can create so much more value in a lot less time. The value that we create is largely through the the conversations we have in our monthly meetings with the client where we give them advice, interpret the numbers, help them with that strategy. And the 1 or 2 hours that we spend delivering that powerful advice is worth way more than a couple of hours we might spend doing a bank reconciliation.
So we should charge by the the value, which is why advisory should be the most profitable service. So what is the value? Well, the value is different for every single every single client. So one of the things that we can do, there's many ways to to come up with the value. But I, I'm an accountant so I love numbers.
And and so I try to route everything in numbers. I teach that when we are trying to sell advisory services and price advisory, we we should be, doing it by demonstrating, demonstrating the impact that we can have on their business through, through numbers, ideas and stories. And let me start with numbers then. So do some calculations with the client, go through and look at the different profit drivers.
What are the things within their business that drives profit? And what if we could work with them to make some small changes in, for example, the way they price or the way they bring a new business to their into their into their business, new clients into their business. And what you find is when you under understand the mathematical model every business has, that drives sales or drives costs, small percentage differences can make a huge difference to results.
For example, if we could put in place a referral system. Most businesses don't have referral systems don't systemize the process of getting referrals word of mouth. But with a simple system, we could increase sales by five, ten, 15% and that could drill down to a a much bigger number on the bottom line. So if we play with some numbers in front of the client and show them the impact on their, their profits, their results, all their top line sales, it can be extraordinary.
And then what we do, though, go back to price question. We should price based on that. In other words, it doesn't matter how long it takes. If you've got two clients, one client that you believe that you could work with them in over 12 months, you could add, $20,000 to their bottom line profit. And another client where you believe that doing the same kind of analysis and things, you could you could at helm add 200,000, you charge more for the latter client because there's more value that you can create.
So we should be focusing on how much value can we create to the client. Demonstrate that shows them that perhaps the numbers and then the price is based on that value. Yeah. And and I would argue that the, the value that we could bring to our clients is way more than probably what most advisors would be comfortable charging, which is a good thing.
In other words, you could bring value to your example. You could bring about $200,000 worth of value, but if you only charge, let's say 24,000 a month, 2000 2000 a month, 24,000 a year, that mean you're making the client, you're showing the client that there's a, that you're only charging them 24,000 a year, and you're potentially going to help them make ten times almost that, which is huge.
You're not charging them 200,000, you're only charging them a fraction of that. It absolutely. And there's and then there's some real problems of actually of being too cheap and under charging. Firstly, if we're looking to sell a highly valuable advisory work and then when we give the price, it's too low. What happens is when people think a price is too low, they think the qualities low and they won't buy.
So when you have a higher price, people perceive, oh, there must be a high quality here. That's great. And secondly, when you charge a higher price, you have more that time and resource in your firm to to go the extra mile and to deliver more value. And if you're not, if you're not constrained by budgets and trying to fit within everything in tight and tight price, if you if you've got more time to spend some time researching and thinking properly about a client, then you can come up with some amazing ideas.
It's going to create even more value. So we owe it to the client. We owe it to charge them more money so we can spend more time doing a much, much better job. Totally. I love that because a lot of people say, well, I can't raise my fees because then I won't. I won't attract these, these clients. But the clients you're not attracting are smaller clients anyways.
And you're you're raising your fees and your you're effectively communicating that. I'm for these types of business owners, not these types of business owners. So you're weeding them. You're weeding out the lower quality, your lower price point business owners anyways. And I mean, it's it's I completely agree with what you're saying. If you raise your fees, you're going to have room in time to be able to provide a really good service.
I just from personal experience, I started out charging charging really, really low for my advisory services. And just because I didn't have anything to price anchor with, I mean, I just I just said throughout a number and, and and the client said, yes. But what I learned over the years is that as I increased my fees, the clients that accepted the higher fees because there was some clients or some prospects who said, no, I don't, I can't afford that or whatnot, but the ones that did accept it were better clients.
They were the ones that that that just it was a more enjoyable engagement because they see the value in advisory services, and they really look forward to the meeting that we had every month. And they implemented the things that I said, that I advised, and it was just a moral dual experience. And I made more money. That's I mean, that's a great point, Adam, because, I do a lot of learning and I buy a lot of video based courses.
I bought hundreds of budget video based course over the years. And when I buy courses, sometimes those courses, 97 bucks, sometimes even free, and sometimes they're two, three grand when they're free or really cheap. I often think I'll watch that sometime, but I'm not in a rush. Where's the ones I pay two three grand for because I've invested more money?
I want to make sure I work through it. Get all that, suck out all the knowledge, do stuff, and I get more value and more results. And it's the same as what you said. If we if our clients are paying us more money, then they want to make sure they're getting their money's worth. So they will then take the meeting seriously.
They'll go away and take the actions that you're recommending and they'll get better results. They get more value. Totally love that. Hey, they're at a lean with the CFO project podcast. Are you an employed accountant or bookkeeper that would like to start an advisory service on the side? Well, we have a free training for you called Side Hustle CFO.
We will show you how to start a business on the side, offering CFO and advisory services to small business owners. We conduct this training every Friday at 3:00 pm eastern and 12:00 pm Pacific. Go to the CFO project. Com and click on Free trainings to register. All right. What's our next question? Phil wants to know when it comes to pricing.
Should I offer various packages like a good, better, best, or should I offer one service for all of my clients? Thoughts? Mark. Great question. You must give people choices. If you give a single fixed price, a single price, your price is wrong, guaranteed every single time and here's the reason everybody has what's called a maximum willingness to pay economist.
Call it a buyer's reservation price. So when anybody wants to buy something, let me give you an example. Let's talk tax returns for a second. So you have, you have a client coming in to buy your tax service. And you talk about what you do, and then you give a price, let's say 750 bucks, the probability that price is exactly the number in their head as being the maximum that they're willing to pay is almost zero.
They will have a number in their mind. They're willing to pay, and that number will either be higher or lower. So let's say they, thinking, as you explain in your tax term service, this is pretty cool. This will save me some stress and some hassle. This has got to be worth 500 bucks. And then you say when they ask the price question it's 750.
Then they're going to say that's too expensive. You lose out. They don't buy in. But also what happens is what about it's a client's thinking as you're talking and building up the value of your tax prep service. That's thinking, wow, this is going to save me so much stress. I've always stressed about my tax and I hate spending time doing it.
This has got to be worth at least 1500 bucks. And you then say it's 750. They say yes and you celebrate thinking yes, I'm a great sales person, but you've left money on the table. So with a single fixed price, you lose every single time. We need to do with value. Pricing is set our price as close as possible to the maximum willingness to pay.
The trouble is, we don't know what that number is. We cannot ask the client what is the most you're willing to pay because they either won't answer or they'll lie and give you a lower number. We're not mind readers, so we have to use techniques for doing it. And one of those is what I call it. Menu pricing is giving three choices.
So going back to the tax return, if you had a basic tax return service at $500, one at 750 and a premium at, let's say at 1250, then you're going to capture different types of people. The person that comes in that sees huge value, they will happily pay you the 1250 premium service because they see the value. If you don't have a more expensive option, your clients don't have to the ability to pay you more money.
And yet, some clients will want more stuff and will want to give you more money. Yeah, no, I love that that that makes complete sense, especially when it comes to to bookkeeping and in tax services where you sort of have to list out exactly what they're getting for the price point that they're paying. And some people value getting more stuff.
I also find it interesting because I read a lot of stuff on, you know, pricing and whatnot. There's a do you have do you have Costco's over there in England? It's like a white House. I'm in Portugal, so I think we have an equivalent, but I'm not sure we have Costco. I was reading a study that Costco, they have a, it's a friend of theirs, and it's just a it's like a big warehouse store memberships.
You have to be a member to go in, and they sell mayonnaise, you know, jars that could feed an army. They have a jewelry counter, and they did a study one time. They would sell this jewelry, and they would price at a certain point, they then they with one location, they decided to add a, a very expensive piece of jewelry, like a $20,000 piece of jewelry.
Everything else was like, you know, below 3000 or something. They weren't they weren't they did not put that in there because I expected somebody to buy it. They put that in there to price anchor the jewelry because of the store that didn't have the $20,000 piece of, of jewelry, all of a sudden a to $2,000 piece of jewelry looked expensive.
But then when you put it next to a $30,000 piece of jewelry or expensive jewelry, all of a sudden the $2,000 piece of jewelry looks cheap in comparison. And they sold way more at that location that they put that expensive jewelry. So it's all about price anchoring and positioning and, and and you know, what you said completely makes sense in terms of price.
Absolutely. And in the world of price psychology, I would argue that anchoring is the number one most powerful principle in price psychology. We should be using it all of the time. So, for example, if we are selling advisory services and pricing them, we should absolutely give different options, different choices. Think of it as the bronze, silver, gold or the good better best.
But what we should also do with advisory is when they ask the price. We always talk about the most expensive option first and reveal the price of the most expensive. And we purposely make it crazy expensive, not because we necessarily want anyone to buy it. If they do, that's great, but it's so the next one down which which the one we really want to sell seems like such a great boring.
Yeah. Oh man. Mark, we could go all day on this topic I think this is fantastic. So we'll we'll make sure you come back on the podcast. Before we go, where can people learn more about you and value Pricing Academy? Oh, wow. Loads of loads of places. So first thing I would always recommend is go and connect with me on LinkedIn.
And every time somebody connects on LinkedIn and they say, I saw you on the podcast, I will send back a message with a link to a whole bunch of free resources, pricing resources and so on that people can grab. So just connect on LinkedIn. That's the best thing to do. If you want to find out more about the Value Pricing Academy, my website is WW.
Wickersham Kwik e Shalom. Co.Uk I guess perhaps Adam, you'll be able to share the links. Yeah, yeah, of course we'll put that in the show notes and all the socials and whatnot. Mark, thank you so much for being on the show today. You're welcome, I loved it. Thank you for inviting me. And to everyone listening, if you haven't already, sign up for our weekly newsletter for.
It's a five minute weekly email with practical tips for accountants and bookkeepers to escape the accountants trap. Go to the CFO project.com/newsletter. See you next time on the CFO project podcast.