Episode 80: Why Vulnerable Leadership Is the Future of Accounting
      Free training this week on becoming a CFO​​​​​​​       

Episode 80

Why Vulnerable Leadership Is the Future of Accounting

Episode 80

Why Vulnerable Leadership Is the Future of Accounting

 Watch the full episode 

In this episode, Adam sits down with Randy Crabtree—partner at Tri-Merit and mental health advocate—to discuss how vulnerability in leadership is transforming accounting firms.

Randy shares his personal journey, including how a life-changing stroke and years of mental health challenges led him to reevaluate his role and purpose.

He explains how leaning into vulnerability as a leader not only sparked 12x firm growth, but also drastically improved team morale, innovation, and retention.

This episode dives deep into how CFOs and firm owners can embrace authentic leadership to build sustainable, people-first organizations.

 Highlights from this episode 

What the Future of Accounting Looks Like

Characteristics of Most Leaders Today

What is a Vulnerable Leader

Why Vulnerable Leadership is Important

Free Live Training this Week

Learn the Strategies to Become a CFO for Small Businesses

Discover how to earn $192,000 per year as a CFO for small businesses.

If you're tired of competing on price, working long hours and/or just want to have more of an impact on your clients' lives you need to become a CFO to small businesses.

This training is eligible to receive CPE credit.

settings
Secure Your Spot

Transcript



In this episode of the CFO project podcast, we discuss how to grow your practice by taking calculated risk. By being a vulnerable leader.

Adam. Thanks for having me here. I'm, looking forward to having a fun discussion today.

Yeah. So it's funny, I I've, I've gone through these cycles of of looking at our firm and and why and we're, we've been very successful and why we've been successful and, and I've had these different iterations. You know, I first looked at mental health awareness and burnout and do we deal with that and we don't. Then I looked at okay, it's because we have a people first culture.

And then I'm like, okay, so that's good. But why? And then I came to, you know, whether it's all based on vulnerability their ship and and so vulnerable leadership. It's a it's not a new term. It's actually out there a lot of books on that and people talking about it, but they've just gotten super passionate about it because it's it there's so many positive impacts to vulnerable leadership.

And so what what I've seen and we've lived it personally, but what I've seen is a vulnerable leader is just not afraid to, ask for help, not afraid to make a mistake and admit it, not afraid to show that they don't have all the answers. And which kind of goes backwards to what we probably been taught as leaders.

Hey, as a leader, you have to have all the answers. You have to be strong. You have to show that there's no weakness there. And so, you know, when we dig into the vulnerability aspect of it, it's just amazing the statistics out there that show the positive impact that vulnerable leadership in general has on an organization.

why is vertical leadership a topic that's needed to be talked about specifically in the accounting profession?

Specifically in a county, because we we are more so, I think, than other professions. So stuck on this. We have to be perfect that that perfection that we can never have make a mistake, that we have to be correct. And it's proven out in statistics, if we look at the profession just in general, or at least it points to this in statistics, you know, over the last three years we've lost 300,000 accountants in the profession.

In the next, in the next 13 years, 75% of the CPAs are going to be retiring. Most of those in the next five years, 75%. Yeah. It's this is an AICPA stat out there. I'm in that group that I am the end of the baby boomers. We're we're aging now. And, that's happened in attendance in, in undergrad and grad programs is down.

I think it's down 20% since like 2018. The positive is there was a 12% uptick this past fall. So that's a little sign, a little teeny dent. But then the other part, why vulnerable leadership is needed is the attrition rates in our profession. We lose. I think it's about 21% of first year accountants leave the profession. And then the first three years and I'm going off the top of my head, but I think it's about 41% leave compared to about 28% in corporate.

So you just see there there's a disconnect. Our profession obviously has people leaving at a much greater rate than just corporate roles in general. And I think part of that is just this whole leadership structure of this is how it has to be. You have to work 80 hours a week. The tax season has to and has to be this terrible thing.

And it's just this mindset. So when we have vulnerable leadership involved, I see a positive impact on all that.

Yep.

Yeah. No, for sure, if I hey, I don't want to work for somebody that's that's afraid to admit a mistake. I mean, I know those are most likely going to be the people. Those are the micro managers, too, because, hey, this has to be perfect. Look at this. Yeah. You you you forgot to put the tea all the way across the top of that line there.

So it looks like it might not mean just all those little things. But when I can admit that, hey, I can give you a real life example of how this had an impact on our organization, if you want. So this will, I'll try to make this a quick story. But, the 11 year and I'll go quick that 11 years ago, I had a stroke.

Now, this isn't this. This isn't the story, but this is the start of this story. I, I recovered very quickly from that stroke. Physically, but mentally I did not. It took me about four and a half years, you know, PTSD, PTSD, panic attacks, depression, anxiety, all these things because, you know, I was going to have another stroke and I was going to die.

And so all these things ran through my head. But when I when I came out of that, when I, when I realized, you know what, my head's playing tricks on me. That's that this is not happening. I'm just convincing myself that this is the future for me and it's not. And so I finally decided to take control back of my mind and my mindset and when I did that, I kind of looked at what have I been lying to myself about all these years?

Because I'd probably let my brain play tricks on me in the past. And I've been an entrepreneur since I was 16. I've started many businesses. Try married. I started 18 years ago in 2000, 17. I finally looked at this and I said, okay, what what have I been doing wrong from a standpoint of am I living and what I'm passionate about?

Am I living what I call now, the intersection of your passion and your skills? And I looked at it and I go, you know, I managing partner this business, I started this business. We have a really nice business and my really managing partner do I have to if I've been tricking myself that that's my role. Have I been lying to myself that this is the role I have to be just because I started it?

And when they did that, I looked at, I said, no, this is not more my skills are. So I'm going to be vulnerable. I'm going to say, this isn't I'm not good at this magic partner. I can start a business. There's a point in time where I shouldn't be managing the business. And so I looked at this and I, I went to the organization.

I said, hey, I have to step down from this role. I'm not suited for this role. This is not where my skills are. That's not where my passions are. This is not what I should be doing. So right there I was being vulnerable, obviously, and I didn't even look at this as a vulnerable leadership moment. It was just this is this is something I have to change.

The impact of that is it ended up being leadership because people realized, I can say the same thing. I can I can look at what I'm doing and determine, is this really where I should be in the organization? Is this the role that I'm most passionate about? Is this the role that I can thrive in and enjoy, have joy in my in my in my role?

And when everybody started doing that, it was just this, this ripple effect. And over a five year period, we 12 times our growth. For the last three years, we've been named, one of the top five fastest, top 5000, top five would be something top 5000 fastest growing privately held companies in the US. Our attrition rate, is unbelievably low.

In 18 years, we're at 80 people now. I think we've had ten people leave, and I can tie that all back to the leadership styles that we've had from day one. And so people just are are engaged in the organization. They feel they can share their ideas, they feel they can make mistakes and be innovative. That is a real life story that has a major impact on their organization.

Oh, awesome. Yeah, yeah.

Yes.

Yeah. And honestly, I didn't even look at that. Is is, you know, is a leadership moment I just looked at is this is not where I'm enjoying living right now at this role. But then when I think deeper, it's like. So now I want everybody in our organization to align themselves with their passions and their skills.

Because if every organization can do that and what you just said makes a lot of sense, find the the who. Because there's things that everybody in every organization, there's things in that organization where you don't like doing and you're bad at it, but there's somebody else in that organization. If you're an organization of any size, this somebody is going to love and good at the things that you're bad and hate doing.

And so why not align people with those roles? You, you you can't help but thrive in that situation.

Yep.

Nope.

Yep. And. Nope. Analyze your roles. Analyze what you do. There's actually a little Excel spreadsheet that someone else turned me on to do to kind of analyze that. It's just, it's just a love it, hate it. Go that bad, that list all your task. Check it. My good at it. They're bad at it. Check. Do I love it or do I hate it?

And then you go across the board and you can find the places you're good and you love. And you can find the pieces. You're bad in your head. And if there's things you love and you're bad that, well, maybe that's the one thing you try to improve if you love it, but you just have it there yet. Otherwise, if you're bad at it and you hate it, automate, delegate, eliminate.

Figure a way that someone else can do that.

Man, you are getting me excited here today. This is this is, I feel like I've, turned up my voice a couple octaves.

Everybody listening. If you haven't already, sign up for our five minute weekly email with practical tips for accountants and bookkeepers to escape the accountants trap. Go to the CFO project.com/newsletter.

if you're saying that leaders need to be vulnerable, that implies that most leaders are probably not. So what are characteristics of most leaders now, especially in the accounting industry?

Yeah, I think it's just that stoic leadership. It's like, you know. Hey, this is. I'm in charge. I'm. I'm managing this. Go to that lovely event. I'm. Or I'm manager. I'm supervisor. I'm in charge. You know, this is my way. We're going to do it. This and and we're going to, you know, I'm I'm not going to show that I have any weakness.

I'm going to display bad behavior because I'm going to work 80 hours a week because this is how you get ahead in this profession. I'm going to I'm going to brag about my 3000 billable hours. And that is just completely opposite. I think of how you build a sustainable, growing organization.

No it's not. And we have to realize that we have to I think, again, there's a lot of people, you know, in my generation that are just like, all right, you know what? The next generation can handle that I'm going to be. I got five years, I got two years. I'm going to retire. And that mindset is just going to, you know, basically start this downward trend for your organization because you're not going to attract the next generation of CPAs.

I, I truly believe that the Gen Z is going to be a it's going a little far to say Savior, but I think they're going to have a major positive impact on the accounting profession. They, from what I hear, no expert. But what I hear is, you know, they went through 2008 as kids. They went through the pandemic while they're in college or whatever.

They see accounting as a stable, place to land as a, as a profession. But they're not going to put up with this, the stoic leadership, they, they want to share their ideas. They want to have innovation in the organization. And when you don't have vulnerable leadership, innovation and creativity are stifled.

Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Oh, no. I have.

Yeah, it's too much. I mean, I can look at my second, second firm. I worked at the managing partner that was at that firm was that, you know, there was no vulnerable leadership involved. In fact, it was micromanaged to the max. And it's actually a job I walked out on. I just packed up my desk one day and left because I was not going to deal with that type of leadership.

so Randy, let me ask you. We talked about characteristics of somebody that's not a vulnerable leader. What are some characteristics of somebody that is a vulnerable leader?

Yeah, it's it's, basically kind of said it, but it's there's a difference between vulnerability and vulnerable leadership. And so a vulnerable is I don't have the answer in vulnerable leadership as I don't have the answer. But I need your help to get here. And so I don't I vulnerable vulnerability is I made a mistake. Vulnerable leadership is I made a mistake.

And here's the impact of it. But here's what I learn from it. Those types of things. Anybody can be vulnerable and you should be vulnerable. But vulnerability by itself doesn't necessarily have a positive impact. What do we do with that vulnerable moment is where the impact is made. And so that's what we just have to look in.

I mean I can believe me, I can I can just sit on the call with our team and I can cry because I get so emotional and so they're so important to me. But crying doesn't, you know, create leadership, you know, that is if I say you know, you're doing an amazing job and this is the innovation you've showed here and that, that, that, new service line you just put together, it's unbelievable that you thought, I mean, if you have this reinforcement, positive feedback to do business.

Now, it's not all that. I mean, sometimes you have to say, okay, yes, this was a misstep, but this is what we learn from it and it's okay to make missteps. So yeah, it's, it's, yeah, it's it's important.

Yeah. That's, I mean, you can give me your give me go ahead. And something else then. But leadership in general, just that I have this blind spot with the word leadership. It's because when I see when I hear leadership, I, I, I don't know why. Maybe just the way I came up in the profession, I think leaders up here at the top and then everybody else is down here.

But to me, when I look at leadership, it's a it's a straight line. Everybody in the organization has an opportunity to lead and should have an opportunity and should lead. And so it's just my mental block with the word. But this is how I see leadership is, hey, we all have a positive impact on this organization. And so we all should be able to share our ideas and innovation and creativity and and and mistakes and missteps.

Yep.

Yep.

Yep. Let me that is a there's a great point. And what you just said is the people are important. And this is another part of vulnerable leadership to me, getting to know the people you work with on a personal level. And hey everybody can know that you're a, audit manager. Great. But that's not defining you. That's not who you are.

Sure you're a CPA or an another manager? That's part of who defines you. But you are a, a mountain climber. You're a, a craft beer enthusiast. You're a musician, you're an artist, you're a parent, you're a coach. Those are the things that define you. And when vulnerable leaders take the time to get to know people at that level, that's another way.

So I do a satisfaction survey in the profession. That alone was the second highest satisfaction creator in the accounting world is when individuals felt they were known by their coworkers in their bosses on a personal level, second highest, satisfaction creator. Yeah.

Well, thanks for asking about that. This type of stuff and some things we talk about at Bridging the Gap Conference, that's a conference that I, that I host, it's going to be July 22nd, 23rd and 24th in Denver, Colorado this year. I'm not sure if this will run before that or after that, but, if not, you can look at the future years.

It is a it came out of my passion for mental health awareness and burnout prevention in the accounting world. And then it's grown from there. It's practice management. It's just it's just individuals in the profession sharing ideas that are going to help us all, improve as a, as a profession, as a person and, and as the people we work with.

So it is it is fun. It is getting a lot of positive reviews over the last two years. This is year three. And, my keynote is going to be, on, vulnerability and the fear of change and the impact that, embracing those have.

Yeah. If I can give you more than a couple less words, I appreciate it. So obviously, you can hear me rant and you can hear me rave and you can hear me say all this stuff, but there is statistics out there and statistics in my mind. I'm a numbers guy. Statistics don't lie. And so if you want to find out you can research these.

But like Harvard Business Review did a survey that says, you know, employees are, 25% more engaged when there's vulnerable leadership, creativity and innovation goes up by 30% when there's, vulnerable leadership, employee resilience goes up by 40% when there's. And this is the Gallup did one American Psychology Association dinner. One. Harvard did one, University did one.

And one of the key things is trust levels go up by 60% when there's vulnerable leadership. So all those are going to have a major positive impact on your organization. So I would definitely look into, leaning into vulnerable leadership.

And thank you. It's been fun.
Free Live Training this Week

Learn the Strategies to Become a CFO for Small Businesses

Discover how to earn $192,000 per year as a CFO for small businesses.

If you're tired of competing on price, working long hours and/or just want to have more of an impact on your clients' lives you need to become a CFO to small businesses.

This training is eligible to receive CPE credit.

settings
Secure Your Spot
 By professionals, for professionals. 

Resources:

GENERAL INQUIRIES:

INTERESTED IN PARTNERSHIPS?

MEMBERS:

arrow_downward

NASBA Statement:

 
 The CFO Project is registered with the National Association of State Boards of Accountancy (NASBA) as a sponsor of continuing professional education on the National Registry of CPE Sponsors. 
arrow_downward
 
 Copyright 2026 - The CFO Project® 
[bot_catcher]